| 1980 | Mark Colgan (New Castle, IN) |
| 1981 | Steve Coates (Decatur, IL) |
| 1982 | David Laprad (Oakdale, KY) |
| 1983 | Tim Huff (Oakdale, KY) |
| 1984 | Peter Samuelson (Winona Lake, IN) |
| 1985 | Jim Egyud (Monacrest, PA) |
| 1986 | Peter Samuelson (McPherson, KS) |
| 1987 | Johnny Mantor (Anderson (North), IN) |
| 1988 | Laura Christensen (Wenatchee, WA) |
| 1989 | James Huffman (Bloomington, IN) |
| 1990 | Greg Fields (McPherson, KS) |
| 1991 | Scott Sittig (N. Chili (Pearce), NY) |
| 1992 | Shannon Mullis (Bedford, IN) |
| 1993 | Timothy Housel (Bedford, IN) |
| 1994 | Josh Green (McPherson, KS) |
| 1995 | Jason Lidberg (Bedford, IN) |
| 1996 | James Kramer (Willamina, OR) |
| 1997 | Dusty Lannon (Bedford, IN) |
| 1998 | Doug Whitlock (Springfield, IL) |
| 1999 | Nathan Luer (Greenville, IL) |
| 2000 | James Slager (Spring Arbor, MI) |
| 2001 | Blake Houghtaling (Vandalia, IL) |
| 2002 | Patrick Willis (Willamina, OR) |
| 2003 | Adam King (Vincennes, IN) |
| 2004 | Brian Bither (Indianapolis (John-Wesley) IN) |
| 2005 | Annie Haight (Auburn, WA) |
| 2006 | Stephen Coates (Indianapolis (Aldersgate), IN) |
| 2007 | Amy Bither (Indianapolis (John-Wesley) IN) |
| 2008 | |
| 2009 | |
